hoopie

French Knot Problems: Why They Fail and How to Fix Them

Fix French knot problems: knots pulling through, loose loops, messy knots, uneven sizes and tangles. Simple causes and fixes for perfect knots.

By Ayoub Farid · · 2 min read

French knots have a reputation, but nearly all failures come down to a handful of causes. Match your problem below to the fix. (New to French knots? Start with the French knot guide.)

Round, tight mustard French knots
Round, tight French knots.

The knot pulls through to the back

Cause: going down in the exact hole you came up from. The knot has nothing to sit on.

Fix: go down one or two fabric threads away from where you came up.

The knot is loose and loopy

Cause: the working thread wasn't held taut as you pulled the needle through.

Fix: hold the thread firmly with your non-needle hand and keep tension until the needle is almost all the way through. Then release.

The knot is messy or lumpy

Causes: wraps made far from the needle tip; wraps crossing over each other; too many wraps.

Fixes:

  • Wrap close to the tip.
  • Keep wraps side by side, not on top of each other.
  • Use 1–2 wraps. For a bigger knot, use more strands, not more wraps.

Knots are different sizes

Cause: varying wrap counts, strand counts or tension.

Fix: decide on one recipe (e.g. 3 strands, 2 wraps) and stick to it for the area.

The thread tangles into a knot on the back

Cause: twisted thread.

Fix: let the needle dangle to untwist every few knots (thread tangling).

Wraps won't slide off the needle

Cause: the eye is wider than the shaft, or wraps are too tight.

Fix: use a milliner's needle and wrap a little more loosely.

Knot sits on its side, not round

Cause: the needle went down at an angle.

Fix: insert the needle straight down, perpendicular to the fabric.

Quick checklist

  1. Fabric drum-tight
  2. 1–2 wraps, close to the tip
  3. Down next to (not in) the exit hole
  4. Thread taut while pulling through
  5. Same recipe for every knot

Still struggling?

Try a colonial knot: its figure-eight wrap holds more firmly. Or practise in Hoopie's French knots lesson, where the animated guide has a slow mode and the photo coach tells you whether your knots are round, tight and even.

Frequently asked questions

Why do my French knots keep disappearing?

You're going down in the same hole you came up from. Go down just beside it.

Why are my French knots loose?

The thread wasn't held taut as you pulled through. Keep tension until the needle is almost through.

How many wraps should a French knot have?

One or two. Use more strands for a bigger knot.

What needle is best for French knots?

A milliner (straw) needle.

Keep reading